Title
Recommendation to Receive a Status Update on the Clement Avenue Truck Route between Grand Street and Sherman Street and Direct Staff to Maintain the Existing Truck Route or Evaluate Other Truck Route Options for Further Consideration; and
Adoption of Resolution Amending Fiscal Year 2026-27 Budget Appropriation from the General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance for Costs Associated with a General Plan Amendment to Amend the City’s Designated Truck Route. (Public Works 31041520)
Body
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
From: Gerry Beaudin, City Manager
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Skyline development project at 2015 Grand Street (former Pennzoil facility) has completed the final gap in Clement Avenue extension, and the roadway from Hibbard Street to Grand Street is ready to open to traffic. Relocation of the truck route from Buena Vista Avenue to Clement Avenue between Sherman Street and Grand Street has long been a component of the City of Alameda’s (City) General Plan. City Council requested a status update and expressed interest in considering other truck route options. This report presents five potential options, including maintaining the truck route on Clement Avenue, to City Council for consideration. Additional analysis, public outreach, and a General Plan Amendment (GPA) would be required if City Council directs Staff to consider truck route option(s) other than on Clement Avenue between Grand Street and Sherman Street. Evaluation and consideration of a GPA is anticipated to take 9-12 months. Additionally, staff recommends an interim action to open Clement Avenue to vehicular traffic at Grand Street prior to completion of the GPA.
BACKGROUND
History
The truck route map from the 1990 General Plan (Exhibit 1) included east-west truck routes through the central portion of Alameda Island on seven roadways: Shore Line Drive, Otis Drive, Encinal Avenue, Central Avenue, Lincoln Avenue, Buena Vista Avenue, and Clement Avenue. In 2009, City Council approved an updated General Plan Transportation Element which consolidated the truck routes to three: Encinal Avenue, Clement Avenue including the planned Clement Avenue Extension, which was not fully constructed in 2009, and Buena Vista Avenue between Grand Street and Sherman Avenue. The current General Plan truck route map approved with the Street Classification Appendix in 2023 explicitly identifies the truck route portion on Buena Vista Avenue as temporary (Exhibit 2). The changes in 2009 and 2023 reflect a goal of limiting the number of streets where truck traffic is allowed. No substantive physical changes occurred to the roadways where truck routes were removed, and all seven roadways identified in 1990 as truck routes remain technically viable as truck routes.
The Clement Avenue Extension between Hibbard Street and Entrance Road was defined in 2000 by City Council Resolution 13290, which approved plans for 152 lots at Marina Cove (Tentative Map 7170). The Improvement Plans for Tract 7170 included the construction of Clement Avenue with a 42-foot roadway section consisting of two 12-foot lanes, 5-foot-wide on-street bike lanes and an 8-foot parking lane on the southern side of Clement Avenue. The curvilinear alignment for the length of Clement Avenue, with several 250-foot radius curves between Entrance Road and Hibbard Street, was approved with Tract 7170 and right-of-way dedicated on the map. The Marina Cove project explicitly acknowledged that Clement Avenue may be designated as a future truck route in the General Plan and disclosure statements were recorded on the property title for all lots fronting Clement Avenue.
The Cross Alameda Trail Feasibility Study was approved by City Council in 2005. The feasibility plan distinguishes between a commuter trail alignment and a recreational trail alignment. The commuter trail alignment was envisioned on Clement Avenue, and the recreational trail alignment would be along Buena Vista Avenue, Pacific Avenue, or along the estuary shoreline. The Bike Master Plan was updated in 2010, and the recreational trail alignment in this area was relocated to Clement Avenue as a proposed Class II on-street bike lane facility. The Tentative Map for Tract 8118, the second phase of the Marina Cove development, was approved by the Planning Board on November 26, 2012, showing Class II on-street bike lanes, consistent with the Bike Master Plan.
In March 2013, the City adopted new bike lane standards under which the design for the Cross Alameda Trail is noted as a Class I or Class IV facility (i.e a two-way separated cycle track with a 12-14 foot width). However, there was no change to the planned Class II bike lanes between Sherman Street and Grand Street at that time.
In 2014 the Del Monte Development Plan was reviewed and approved by the Planning Board and City Council with a two-way cycle track on Clement Avenue across the project frontage from the newly constructed intersection at Sherman/Atlantic/Clement to Entrance Road.
During the May 27, 2014, Planning Board hearing for the Marina Cove II project, the City asked the developer to extend the on-street cycle track along the project frontage to create a continuous, separated cycle track from Alameda Point to Broadway. The design review package includes a Clement Avenue cross-section showing the on-street cycle track, and the Tract 8118 improvement plans were amended to include construction of a cycle track on the northern side of Clement Avenue between Entrance Road and Ohlone Street. The revised roadway configuration includes an 8-foot parking lane, 2 two 10.5-foot travel lanes, and the separated two-way cycle track.
The Tentative Map for the Skyline development at 2015 Grand Street was approved by City Council on February 7, 2023. The project includes the dedication and construction of Clement Avenue between Hibbard Street and Grand Street, the final gap in the long-planned Clement Avenue extension between Sherman Street and Grand Street. The Skyline development project has completed construction of Clement Avenue, and City staff has directed the developer to keep the roadway closed until a determination is made regarding the relocation of the truck route from Buena Vista Avenue to Clement Avenue per the General Plan.
Truck Route Lane Widths
Truck routes provide a network of streets for truck access to serve the delivery and material transportation needs of residents and businesses. The goal of the truck route network is to limit the number of streets on which truck traffic is allowed. Streets on truck routes facilitate truck movement by providing adequate lane widths and turning space. Truck traffic is allowed to use streets outside the truck route when necessary to reach the destination. The Clement Avenue Extension is identified as a truck route in the City of Alameda Street Classifications appendix to the General Plan. Clement Avenue is also listed as a Neighborhood Connector and Transit Route in the Street Classifications.
Truck routes are designed to accommodate larger vehicles, including the horizontal offset that occurs when a large tractor-trailer navigates a tight-radius curve. The rear of the trailer will track a tighter radius than the front of the truck, necessitating a wider travel lane to safely accommodate the movement. A typical full-size truck with a 42-foot trailer (WB-50 truck) would need about 13 feet of lane width to account for the trailer offset caused by the curvilinear alignment on Clement Avenue while providing some tolerance for human behavior. Accordingly, minimum 13-foot-wide lanes are recommended for the proposed truck route on Clement Avenue between Balsa Street and Hibbard Street.
Existing lane widths on Clement Avenue are too narrow to accommodate the expected truck traffic, and sideswipe collisions with moving vehicles and/or parked cars would be a likely outcome. Though not preferred due to potential truck-bicyclist conflicts, the on-street bike lanes included in the original 2000 design would have provided sufficient unobstructed width to accommodate a large truck. It does not appear that truck traffic and offset requirements were factored into the 2014 decision to construct a separated two-way cycle track on the Clement Avenue extension. With the completion of the Clement Avenue Extension and in preparation to open to traffic, the City hired Parametrix in 2026 to conduct a swept path and lane width analysis for Clement Avenue (Exhibit 3). The purpose of the study was to determine the minimum lane widths required to accommodate different use cases on Clement Avenue, which could then be used to develop implementation plans.
The preferred solution to open the Clement Avenue extension to traffic, including trucks, is to widen each travel lane to a minimum of 13 feet, which would require eliminating on-street parking on Clement Avenue between Balsa Street and Paru Street. Approximately 21 on-street parking spaces would be lost on this portion of Clement Avenue. Additional improvements are required at Clement Avenue and Stanton Street, where existing concrete bulb-outs further constrain lane widths, including the partial removal of the western bulb-out and the narrowing of the cycle track in the immediate vicinity of the intersection. The bulb-out that requires narrowing is not where the crosswalk is located. The City recently added rapid-flashing beacons at Clement Avenue and Stanton Street to improve pedestrian safety in anticipation of Clement Avenue's opening to all vehicles. The bulb-out where the rapid-flashing beacons are would not be narrowed. A preliminary layout of the modifications at Clement Avenue and Stanton Street is included in Exhibit 4.
In early 2026, the City hired Dixon Resources Unlimited, a parking consultant with prior experience in Alameda, to evaluate the potential impact of on-street parking loss on the community (Exhibit 5). The study area included the entire Marina Cove development from Entrance Way to Hibbard Street and from Clement Avenue to the southern side of Buena Vista Avenue and included mid-week and weekend counts at various times of the day. The study findings indicate that Clement Avenue is generally lightly parked, with less than 50% occupancy, and sufficient on-street parking capacity exists within the community to accommodate the parking loss on Clement Avenue.
The loss of parking could be partially offset with up to 15 new parking spots on Buena Vista Avenue after the truck route is formally shifted to Clement Avenue. Most of Buena Vista Avenue is striped for two lanes of travel with parking on both sides of the street. Within the temporary truck route between Sherman Street and Grand Street, a two-way left-turn lane is provided to accommodate the high volume of trucks and left turns. As a consequence, no parking is allowed on the north side of the street. Following the transition of the truck route to Clement Avenue per the General Plan, Buena Vista Avenue could be restriped, allowing parking on the northern curbline, resulting in a net loss of only seven on-street parking spaces to the community.
Public Outreach
Public outreach to date has been limited to those potentially affected by the loss of parking on Clement Avenue from Paru Street to Balsa Street, including the full blocks from Entrance Road to Hibbard Street, and Clement Avenue to Buena Vista Avenue. Notification letters were sent to residents informing them of a July 14, 2026, community meeting and an informational item presented to the Transportation Commission on July 22, 2026. Extensive community feedback was provided at both meetings, and much of it was captured in the July 22, 2026, Transportation Commission Agenda. While the loss of parking is a concern for the community, the primary concern is the truck route designation and its impacts on the community.
Transportation Commissioners were engaged and asked several questions about alternatives. Approximately 15-20 members of the public spoke, with primary themes including quality of life, access to and use of the park, concerns about speed in wider lanes, and reliance on a 20-year-old plan given changed conditions. Nearly all would like the truck route to remain on Buena Vista Avenue, a few thought a City-wide truck route evaluation was warranted. While the Transportation Commissioners generally agreed that City Staff had conducted appropriate due diligence related to the potential parking loss on Clement Avenue, three of the five commissioners present suggested that City Council hear and consider alternative options for the truck route in this area.
On October 6, 2026, City Council unanimously approved a referral item requesting that staff present a status update on the Clement Avenue truck route prior to making physical improvements and directing staff to develop other truck route options.
DISCUSSION
The Clement Avenue Extension through the former industrial northern waterfront between Sherman Street and Grand Street is now complete and ready to open to traffic. The extension was completed in multiple phases as separate private developments, including Marina Cove I, Marina Cove II, Marina Shores, and Del Monte, were constructed along the former waterfront. The Skyline development project at 2015 Grand Street (former Pennzoil facility) completed the final gap in the Clement Street extension in early 2026, but the roadway remains closed until it can be made safe for the expected traffic.
When opened, the roadway will provide direct access for many east-west trips across the northern portion of the island, and traffic volumes will increase dramatically for Clement Avenue between Sherman Street and Grand Street. Traffic analyses completed in 2017 for the Alameda Marina development and in 2022 for the Skyline development suggest that the Clement/Grand intersection will see an estimated 715 through movements on Clement Avenue during the PM peak hour. Using the observed heavy vehicle (truck) percentages of 1-3% in 2017, this would translate to an anticipated 7-22 trucks during the peak hour.
Passenger and light-truck vehicle volumes are largely unaffected by truck route designation, each seeking to maximize utility and reduce travel time independently. Relocating an anticipated 7 to 22 trucks during the peak hour to a new route will not alter the level of service at any specific intersection. Therefore, the truck route is not a traffic volume issue, per se, and it is believed that re-establishment of a truck route on any of the east-west truck routes in the 1990 General Plan is technically possible.
At City Council’s request, staff has identified five options for an east-west truck route serving the northern portion of the main island which may be considered by City Council (Exhibit 6).
Option 1 - Truck Route on Clement Avenue (full length)
Maintaining the truck route on Clement Avenue is consistent with the General Plan and is recommended by Staff. Parking would be removed along the southern edge of Clement Avenue from Balsa Court to Ohlone Street, and the centerline relocated to create a 13-foot-wide westbound travel lane. The two-way cycle track would be narrowed from 11 feet to 8.5 feet wide in the immediate vicinity of Stanton Street, and a portion of the western bulb-out trimmed. The 8.5-foot-wide cycle track would meet minimum standards and is similar to other sections of the Cross Alameda Trail where the trail is narrowed at intersections, driveways, and other conflicts. The eastern bulb out where the existing crosswalk and rapid flashing beacon is located would not be affected.
A truck route on Clement Avenue maintains the most direct access to the commercial, industrial, and maritime uses near the estuary. In addition to a truck route, this option provides sufficient lane width for bus operations and would satisfy the General Plan designation of Clement Avenue as a transit route.
Option 2 - Truck Route on Buena Vista Avenue (portion)
The truck route has been located on Buena Vista Avenue from Sherman Street to Grand Street for many years and functions moderately well. Primary challenges include the difficult 90-degree turns at the Grand/Clement and Grand/Buena Vista Avenue intersections, and the tendency for some trucks to remain on Buena Vista Avenue westbound after Sherman Street or eastbound after Grand Street.
Clement Avenue would remain a Transit Route and would need to accommodate bus traffic. Consideration is also required to account for errant trucks which may miss the truck route signage. A single large tractor-trailer missing a turn and driving Clement Avenue between Balsa Street and Paru Street would cause unavoidable issues with oncoming traffic. Minimum 12-foot lanes are needed for bus traffic or to accommodate an isolated errant truck. Either parking would need to be eliminated as noted in Option 1 or the cycle track narrowed from 11 feet to 9 feet between Balsa Street and Paru Street.
Option 3 - One Way Truck Routes on Clement Avenue (portion) and Buena Vista Avenue (portion)
A one-way truck route couplet on Clement Avenue and Buena Vista Avenue was suggested during community engagement and merits consideration. Westbound truck traffic would continue on Clement Avenue and eastbound truck traffic would use Buena Vista Avenue. It splits the difference in truck exposure between the two streets and eliminates half of the challenging 90-degree turns on Grand Street. Westbound truck traffic would continue on Clement Avenue and eastbound truck traffic would use Buena Vista Avenue.
Limiting truck traffic to westbound on Clement Avenue would require only one 13-foot lane. Either parking would need to be eliminated, as noted in Option 1, or the cycle track would need to be narrowed from 11 feet to 9 feet between Balsa Street and Paru Street to create a wider 13-foot lane. Bus traffic would be accommodated on Clement Avenue with Option 3.
Option 4 - Truck Route on Buena Vista Avenue (full length)
The truck route can be fully removed from Clement Avenue and re-established on Buena Vista Avenue. It is noted that the 1990 Truck Route Map included time limitations, 6:00 am to 10:00 pm, for the truck route on Buena Vista Avenue east of Grand Street.
Assuming time limitations would also be re-established, concerns would remain for trucks continuing through the Clement Avenue Extension. Either parking would need to be eliminated, as noted in Option 1, or the cycle track would need to be narrowed from 11 feet to 9 feet between Balsa Street and Paru Street. Bus traffic would be accommodated on Clement Avenue with Option 3.
Option 5 - Truck Route on Lincoln Avenue (full length)
The truck route can be fully removed from Clement Avenue and re-established on Lincoln Avenue. Lincoln Avenue is wide with sweeping turns dating back to its historic use as a railroad. It can easily accommodate trucks. The biggest drawback is the relative distance from commercial, industrial, and maritime uses adjacent to the estuary. The truck route on Sherman Street would need to be extended south to Lincoln Avenue to serve the east end Marina Village.
While relocating the entire truck route largely avoids the concern about errant trucks continuing through the Clement Avenue Extension, Clement Avenue remains its designation as a transit route and wider lanes are needed to accommodate bus use. Similar to Options 2 through 4, the wider lanes on Clement Avenue can be achieved through parking removal or narrowing the cycle track from 11 feet to 9 feet.
General Plan Amendment and Interim Action
Options 2 through 5 would require a General Plan Amendment (GPA) to formally relocate the truck route. The GPA would include data collection and analysis, public outreach, public hearings at the Planning Board and City Council, environmental review, and adoption of an ordinance.
Since Buena Vista Avenue and Clement Avenue have previously functioned as a truck route, no technical limitations are expected and the GPA is expected to consider community impacts, business needs, use of and potential narrowing of the Cross Alameda Trail, and other practical considerations when alternate truck routes are evaluated. Baseline traffic volumes, turn movements, and heavy vehicle counts will be collected prior to any action at the following intersections: Sherman / Clement, Sherman / Buena Vista, Grand / Clement, and Grand / Buena Vista. Speed and volume surveys will also be collected on Clement Avenue near Sakas Street and Buena Vista Avenue near Sakas Street.
Evaluation and consideration of a GPA is anticipated to take 9-12 months and staff would recommend an interim action to open Clement Avenue to vehicular traffic at Grand Street in early 2027. The interim truck route could relocate to Clement Avenue (Option 1) as a pilot, remain on Buena Vista Avenue (Option 2), or operate as a one-way couplet, eastbound Buena Vista Avenue and westbound on Clement Avenue (Option 3).
As noted above, Options 1, 2, and 3 all require modification to Clement Avenue to accommodate the truck route, errant trucks, and/or buses. The simplest and most cost-effective interim option is to remove parking on Clement Avenue between Balsa Street and Paru Street and restripe to allow either Option 2 or Option 3. In addition to the on-street parking loss, Option 1 would require modification to the cycle track and modification to the western bulb-out near Stanton Street, an unnecessary expense if Clement Avenue does not become the ultimate truck route.
Narrowing the cycle track between Balsa Street and Paru Street is costly and would negatively affect the Cross Alameda Trail. Due to the expense, narrowing the cycle track is only recommended for an ultimate truck route condition and only after impacts are considered as part of a GPA. If appropriate, parking could be re-established along Clement Avenue after the cycle track was narrowed.
ALTERNATIVES
Staff recommends maintaining the truck route on Clement Avenue, removing parking between Balsa Court and Paru Street, and modifying the cycle track and western bulb-out near Stanton Street (Option 1). Alternatives include:
• Direct Staff to consider Option 2 for an alternate truck route and initiate a GPA for evaluation. Maintain interim truck route on Buena Vista Avenue (Option 2) until the GPA is considered; remove parking on Clement Avenue to account for errant trucks.
• Direct Staff to consider Options 2 through 5 for an alternate truck route and initiate a GPA for evaluation. Maintain interim truck route on Buena Vista Avenue (Option 2) until a GPA is considered, remove parking on Clement Avenue to account for errant trucks.
• Direct Staff to consider one or more of Options 2 through 5 for an alternate truck route and initiate a GPA to formalize adoption. Establish an interim truck route on Clement Avenue (Option 1) as a pilot, remove parking on Clement Avenue and modify the cycle track and western bulb-out for the truck route.
• Keep Clement Avenue closed west of Grand Street until a GPA is completed. The Skyline development north of Clement Avenue will be complete and ready for occupancy in early 2027 and continuing to keep Clement Avenue closed to vehicle traffic is not recommended.
• Provide alternate direction to staff.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
The financial impact of this report depends on the direction given by the City Council.
The estimated cost to implement the staff recommendation, Option 1, is approximately $100,000. This includes consultant expenses incurred for the Dixon Resources parking study and Parametrix swept path lane with analysis, expenses for removing parking and restriping Clement Avenue between Balsa Street and Hibbard Street, installing new truck route signage, and modifying the cycle track and western bulb-out at Stanton Street. These costs can be absorbed within the existing Public Works Department FY 2026-27 budget.
However, should the City Council direct staff to pursue any options other than Option 1 presented in this report, staff request a supplemental budget appropriation of $100,000 to cover staff and consultant costs associated with developing the GPA. A Resolution authorizing this appropriation is provided for City Council consideration of this report.
MUNICIPAL CODE/POLICY DOCUMENT CROSS REFERENCE
Maintaining the truck route on Clement Avenue is consistent with the General Plan and truck route map published by the City. A GPA would be necessary to relocate the truck route to an alternate roadway.
Parking Prohibitions and Regulations are contained in Chapter 8 of the Alameda Municipal Code. Per Code Section 8-7.1 the Public Works Director is authorized, “whenever traffic engineering studies or principles indicate for the safety or adequate flow of all modes of transportation, to establish streets or portions thereof where parking is prohibited at all times.” Parking removal along Clement Avenue to establish a truck route as intended in the General Plan would be pursuant to Code Section 8-7.1 and would not be appealable per Code Sections 8-1.2 and 8-1.3.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
The City previously certified an Environmental Impact Report for the Alameda General Plan 2040. Pursuant to CEQA Guidelines sections 15162 and 15163, none of the circumstances necessitating further CEQA review are present if the truck route remains on Clement Avenue.
A separate environmental review will be conducted if a GPA is considered to relocate the truck route.
CLIMATE IMPACT
There are no identifiable climate impacts or climate action opportunities associated with the subject of this report.
RECOMMENDATION
Receive a status update on the Clement Avenue truck route between Grand Street and Sherman Street and direct staff to maintain the existing truck route or evaluate other truck route options for further consideration and adopt a resolution amending Fiscal Year 2026-27 Budget Appropriation from the General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance for costs associated with a General Plan Amendment to Amend the City’s Designated Truck Route.
Respectfully submitted,
Erin Smith, Public Works Director
By,
Scott Wikstrom, City Engineer
Financial Impact section reviewed,
John Stefanski, Interim Assistant City Manager/Acting Finance Director
Exhibits:
1. 1990 General Plan Truck Routes
2. General Plan Street Classification Appendix, 2023
3. Clement Avenue Swept Paths and Lane Widths
4. Conceptual Modifications at Clement and Stanton
5. Clement Avenue Parking Utilization Study
6. Truck Route Options