Title
Adoption of Resolution Adopting the Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan, Including a Location-by-Location Approach to Infrastructure Improvements and Tree Preservation, a Five-Year Tree Removal Cap, and an Exception to the Tree Removal Policy's Five Percent Block-Face Review Requirement.
In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), this action is categorically exempt from further environmental review pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Sections 15301 (Existing Facilities) and 15308 (Protection of the Environment).
Body
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
From: Gerry Beaudin, City Manager
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Gibbons Drive is distinguished by its mature Liquidambar trees, which form a continuous canopy and contribute significantly to the character and environmental quality of the surrounding neighborhood. However, the extensive root systems of these trees, combined with limited growing space, have resulted in widespread damage to sidewalks, curbs, gutters, and other public infrastructure. These conditions pose pedestrian safety concerns and accessibility barriers that the City of Alameda (City) must address.
Building upon the City's existing Sidewalk Repair Program and Tree Removal Policy, the Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan (Plan) provides a community-informed framework that prioritizes the preservation of mature trees, establishes safeguards against rapid canopy loss, and guides the gradual transition to a more resilient replacement canopy that reflects community preferences. Rather than recommending widespread tree removal or corridor reconstruction, the Plan adopts a location-by-location approach to addressing sidewalk and infrastructure conflicts, prioritizing improvements based on the severity of sidewalk damage and the extent of pedestrian accessibility barriers. At each location, staff would evaluate the tree, its root system, and surrounding infrastructure to determine whether repairs can be completed while preserving the tree. Potential solutions include root pruning, sidewalk realignment, raised or bridged sidewalks, curb bulb-outs, and other preservation techniques. Removal of a healthy tree would be considered only as a last resort, when preservation alternatives cannot adequately resolve the infrastructure conflict.
The Plan recognizes that some tree removals may be necessary to address infrastructure conflicts, and that the existing Liquidambars will continue to age and decline over time, requiring removal. To manage a gradual transition and avoid rapid loss of the mature canopy, the Plan establishes a maximum removal cap of 20% of the remaining Liquidambar trees during each five-year period. The cap is a maximum, not a removal target, and all Liquidambar removals, including those resulting from declining tree health or storm damage, would count toward it. This approach allows time for replacement trees to become established while retaining as much of the existing canopy as feasible. As trees are removed over time, the City would plant replacements using a community-informed palette of large-stature species intended to maintain the corridor's distinctive fall color while creating a more diverse and resilient canopy.
The Plan was developed through extensive community engagement, technical analysis, and review by City advisory bodies. Feedback consistently emphasized the importance of preserving the existing canopy, improving pedestrian accessibility, limiting the pace of tree removal, and providing more detail on how the proposed approach would be implemented.
The proposed Plan was refined in direct response to this feedback. Staff reduced the recommended five-year removal cap from 25% of the original Liquidambar population to 20% of the trees remaining at the beginning of each successive five-year period. Under the original approach, the maximum number of allowable removals would have remained constant over time. Under the revised approach, that number decreases as the Liquidambar population declines, recognizing that the need for tree removals associated with infrastructure repairs should also diminish as the most significant conflicts are addressed. Staff also developed a map identifying initial priority locations for infrastructure improvements and a standardized Tree Preservation Evaluation Form to document site conditions, the tree-preservation alternatives evaluated, and the reasons those alternatives may be determined infeasible. The completed form would be made available to the public whenever removal of a healthy tree is proposed, providing greater transparency regarding individual removal decisions.
Importantly, adoption of the Plan would not authorize the removal of any individual tree. Where a tree's root system prevents the City from repairing a sidewalk to meet Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accessibility requirements, removal of a healthy tree would be considered only after reasonable tree-preservation alternatives have been evaluated and determined infeasible. Any proposed removal would remain subject to the City's Tree Removal Policy, including public notification of the Tree Preservation Evaluation Form, and a three-week protest period during which any member of the public may protest by submitting an email to the Public Works Director. Removal decisions may ultimately be appealed to the City Council. These requirements would continue to apply to individual tree removals undertaken in accordance with the Plan.
The Plan proposes one limited exception to the Tree Removal Policy: an additional review requirement by the Planning Board and City Council for capital improvement projects that involve removing more than 5% of street trees on a block face. Because of the relatively small number of trees on each block face along Gibbons Drive, removal of a single tree would exceed this threshold on nine of the ten block faces, while removal of two trees would exceed it on the remaining block face. The proposed exception recognizes that the City Council has reviewed the corridor-wide management framework during the Plan adoption process, thereby avoiding repeated reviews as individual trees are recommended for removal in accordance with the Plan and Tree Removal Policy. All other requirements of the Tree Removal Policy, including the public protest and appeal procedures, would remain in effect.
BACKGROUND
Gibbons Drive Tree Canopy and Existing Infrastructure Conditions
Gibbons Drive was developed during the 1920s and 1930s, and many of its Liquidambar trees are approaching 100 years of age. The mature canopy is a defining feature of the neighborhood, providing shade, seasonal color, wildlife habitat, and other environmental benefits.
The trees are in planting strips approximately four feet wide, between five-foot sidewalks and the roadway. As the trees have matured, their trunks and roots have increasingly outgrown the available space, resulting in significant displacement of sidewalks, curbs, and other infrastructure.
Previous City Planning Efforts
The City's 2010 Master Street Tree Plan, adopted by City Council, recognized the distinctive character of Gibbons Drive and the environmental and neighborhood benefits provided by its mature Liquidambars. However, the plan also identified the infrastructure damage, maintenance concerns, and risks associated with a corridor dominated by a single tree species.
The 2010 plan recommended a systematic transition of the Liquidambar canopy over approximately 20 years, using replacement species capable of providing substantial canopy and seasonal character. That systematic transition was not implemented. Instead, the City generally preserved the existing mature trees while making limited or temporary repairs to adjacent infrastructure.
The draft Urban Forest Master Plan, which City Council considered on February 4, 2025, is intended to replace and build upon the 2010 Master Street Tree Plan, and recognizes the need for a separate, community-informed planning effort for Gibbons Drive.
Rather than simply carrying forward the earlier recommendation, the City initiated a new planning process to evaluate current conditions and policies, consider a range of approaches, and develop a framework informed by community priorities.
Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan
In July 2025, the City retained HortScience | Bartlett Consulting to evaluate the trees and surrounding infrastructure and assist with developing a long-term management strategy.
The assessment evaluated 117 Liquidambar trees and found:
• 0 trees in excellent health
• 88 trees in good condition;
• 24 trees in fair condition; and
• 5 trees in poor condition.
The five trees in poor condition were subsequently removed in April 2026 in accordance with the City's Tree Removal Policy, leaving 112 Liquidambar trees along the corridor.
The assessment also documented substantial infrastructure damage. For the remaining 112 sites, roughly two-thirds of the sidewalk locations have moderate or significant damage, and over 80% of the curbs have the same level of damage. Beyond the physical deterioration of the sidewalks, these conditions present significant challenges to pedestrian accessibility. The City has an obligation under the ADA to provide accessible pedestrian facilities within the public right-of-way. The City's ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan, adopted in June 2024, establishes a framework for identifying and removing existing accessibility barriers over time. Along Gibbons Drive, displaced sidewalks, excessive cross slopes, and other deficiencies can make travel difficult or unsafe, particularly for people using wheelchairs, walkers, and other mobility devices. Addressing these conditions is therefore not simply a matter of infrastructure maintenance, but also an important part of the City's ongoing efforts to improve accessibility and meet its ADA obligations.
DISCUSSION
Building Upon Existing City Programs and Policies
The City already has established policies and programs that guide sidewalk repairs and street tree management, including the Sidewalk Repair Program and Tree Removal Policy. The Sidewalk Repair Program provides a framework for addressing damaged sidewalks, while the Tree Removal Policy requires that preservation alternatives be evaluated before a healthy tree may be removed. These existing programs provide the foundation for addressing conflicts between trees and public infrastructure throughout Alameda.
The Plan builds upon these requirements by establishing a coordinated, community-informed approach tailored to the corridor's unique conditions. Informed by extensive community engagement, the Plan provides a consistent, location-by-location framework for prioritizing infrastructure improvements, evaluating tree-preservation measures, and documenting the basis for decisions affecting individual trees. It also introduces measures not established by existing citywide programs, including a five-year removal cap to safeguard against rapid canopy loss and a replacement tree palette that reflects community preferences for large-stature trees, seasonal fall color, and greater species diversity.
The Plan also proposes a limited exception to the Tree Removal Policy's requirement for additional review by the Planning Board and City Council for capital improvement projects that involve the removal of more than 5% of street trees on a block face. All other requirements of the Tree Removal Policy would remain in effect, including evaluation of preservation alternatives, public notification, a three-week protest period during which anyone in the public can protest by emailing the Public Works Director, and the opportunity to appeal removal decisions to the City Council. The rationale for this proposed exception is discussed in greater detail below.
Proposed Approach to Sidewalk and Infrastructure Improvements
The Plan recommends a location-by-location approach to addressing sidewalk and tree conflicts rather than widespread tree removal or reconstruction of the entire corridor. This approach recognizes that conditions vary considerably along Gibbons Drive and that solutions appropriate for one location may not be feasible at another.
Infrastructure improvements would be prioritized based on the severity of sidewalk damage and degree of pedestrian accessibility barriers. This prioritization is intended to direct available resources toward locations presenting the greatest safety and accessibility concerns while allowing improvements to be implemented over time.
At each location, staff would evaluate the tree, its root system, and the surrounding infrastructure to identify opportunities to complete repairs while preserving the tree. Potential preservation strategies include concrete shaving, careful root pruning, sidewalk realignment or meandering, raised or bridged sidewalks, localized curb modifications, a combination of these techniques, and new technologies as they emerge. The feasibility of each approach would depend on site-specific conditions, including available space, root structure, tree health, drainage, and accessibility requirements.
A central principle of the Plan is that removal of a healthy tree would be considered only as a last resort, after preservation alternatives have been evaluated and determined unable to adequately resolve the infrastructure conflict. The Plan does not identify a predetermined number of trees for removal or authorize removal of individual trees through its adoption.
To promote consistency and transparency, the Plan introduces a standardized Tree Preservation Evaluation Form to document site conditions, the alternatives considered to preserve a healthy tree, and the reasons those alternatives may be infeasible. When removal is proposed, the completed form would be made available during the public notification and protest process. This location-by-location evaluation supports the City's ADA obligations while ensuring that opportunities to preserve mature trees are fully considered before removal is recommended.
Managing the Pace of Tree Removal and Canopy Transition
The Plan recognizes that some tree removals may be necessary to address sidewalk and infrastructure conflicts and that the existing Liquidambars will continue to age and decline over time. Even without infrastructure-related removals, the corridor's canopy will gradually transition as individual trees reach the end of their natural lives.
To manage this transition and safeguard against rapid canopy loss, the Plan establishes a maximum removal cap of 20% of the Liquidambars remaining at the beginning of each five-year period. Because the cap is recalculated based on the remaining trees, the maximum allowable removals decrease over time. This approach recognizes that the need for removals associated with infrastructure repairs should also diminish as the most significant conflicts are addressed. Importantly, the cap is a maximum, not a removal target.
All Liquidambar removals, including those resulting from declining tree health, storm damage, or other public safety concerns, would count toward the cap. This allows the City to adjust the pace of infrastructure-related removals in response to actual canopy loss. For example, if a severe storm results in the loss of several mature trees, the City could focus on the infrastructure repairs in those locations to avoid further accelerating canopy loss. Emergency removals necessary to address immediate public safety hazards would still proceed, even if the cap were reached.
The five-year cap provides an additional safeguard beyond the existing Tree Removal Policy. By accounting for all tree losses and allowing implementation to adapt to changing conditions, it is intended to prevent a rapid reduction in the mature canopy while providing time for replacement trees to become established.
Replacement Tree Strategy
As the existing Liquidambars are removed over time, the City will plant replacement trees in accordance with established urban forestry practices. Community engagement demonstrated strong support for large-stature, deciduous trees that provide shade and seasonal fall color, characteristics that residents particularly value about the existing canopy. These preferences informed the development of a curated replacement tree palette that considers species diversity, long-term tree health, and compatibility with available growing space.
Replacement trees will be planted as existing trees are removed, where suitable planting space is available. The City will also take advantage of opportunities to create additional planting areas through future roadway and infrastructure improvements, where feasible. Over time, this approach will introduce greater species and age diversity, reducing the risks associated with monoculture and trees of similar age while maintaining the shade, seasonal color, and neighborhood character that residents value.
Proposed Exception to the Tree Removal Policy's 5% Review Requirement
Under the City's existing Tree Removal Policy, capital improvement projects involving removal of more than 5% of street trees on a block face require additional Planning Board and City Council review. This requirement applies in addition to the Policy's provisions for evaluating preservation alternatives, notifying the public, allowing a three-week protest period, and providing an opportunity to appeal removal decisions.
The relatively small number of street trees on each block face along Gibbons Drive makes the 5% threshold particularly consequential. On nine of the ten block faces, removal of a single tree would exceed the threshold. On the remaining block face, removal of two trees would exceed it. As a result, even an individual removal determined necessary after a detailed evaluation of preservation alternatives would generally trigger additional review by both the Planning Board and City Council.
The Plan proposes an exception to this additional review requirement for tree removals conducted in accordance with the adopted Plan. The rationale is that the City Council has considered the corridor's overall management approach, including the preservation-first evaluation process, the five-year removal cap, and the tree replacement strategy, during the Plan review and adoption process.
The exception is intended to avoid repeated project-level reviews of individual removals that are consistent with this adopted framework. It would not eliminate the requirement to evaluate preservation alternatives, authorize removal of any particular tree, or reduce the public's ability to participate in or challenge individual removal decisions. All other requirements of the Tree Removal Policy would remain in effect, including public notification, the three-week protest period, and appeal to the City Council.
Community Engagement During Development of the Plan
Community engagement was a central component of developing the Plan. Recognizing the importance of the mature Liquidambar canopy to the surrounding neighborhood and the complexity of balancing tree preservation with infrastructure and accessibility needs, the City conducted an extensive outreach process to inform the recommended approach.
Over more than a year of engagement, the City held six community meetings, including in-person and virtual sessions, to share technical findings, discuss potential management approaches, and obtain community input. Outreach also included mailed notices, surveys, a regularly updated project website, door-to-door outreach, and coordination with the Fernside Homeowners Association.
The initial meetings focused on the condition of the Liquidambar trees, the extent of sidewalk and curb damage, and the challenges associated with preserving the mature canopy while addressing deteriorating infrastructure. Subsequent meetings explored potential solutions, including alternative sidewalk configurations, raised sidewalks, roadway modifications, and a location-by-location approach that would evaluate preservation opportunities before considering tree removal.
Throughout the engagement process, residents consistently emphasized the importance of preserving the mature trees and the distinctive character of Gibbons Drive.
Community feedback helped shape several key elements of the draft Plan, including its preservation-first, location-by-location approach. In response to concerns about the pace of canopy loss, staff reduced the proposed five-year removal cap from 25% of the original Liquidambar population to 20% of the trees remaining at the beginning of each successive five-year period. This change both lowers the percentage and reduces the maximum number of allowable removals over time.
Community input also directly informed the replacement tree strategy, as detailed above. Following requests for more time to consider potential species, the City expanded the tree-selection exercise to an online format, allowing additional residents to participate. The resulting replacement tree palette reflects these preferences while promoting greater species diversity and long-term canopy resilience.
Public Review of the Draft Plan
The City released the draft Plan for public review on October 3, 2026, with a comment period extending through October 23, 2026. Community members were invited to submit written comments or participate in an online survey. The City also presented the draft Plan to the Planning Board, Commission on Persons with Disabilities, and scheduled a discussion with the Historical Advisory Board.
During the public review period, the City received numerous emails and survey responses. These are all included in the Plan's Community Engagement Appendix. Comments reflected a range of perspectives, from residents advocating for stronger tree protections to those emphasizing the urgency of improving sidewalk accessibility. Despite these differences, several common themes emerged.
Many commenters supported the location-by-location approach as a reasonable way to balance tree preservation with needed sidewalk repairs, provided individual evaluations were thorough and consistent. Residents requested clearer documentation of tree and infrastructure conditions, the alternatives considered, and the justification for any proposed removal. Some advocated for a lower removal cap or additional protections for the Liquidambars, while others cautioned against requirements that could delay accessibility improvements. Comments also addressed funding, continued neighborhood involvement, and the importance of prioritizing ADA accessibility.
The public review process reinforced the importance of providing clear, consistent documentation of individual decisions. In response, the Plan incorporates a standardized Tree Preservation Evaluation Form to document site conditions, preservation alternatives evaluated, and the reasons those alternatives may be infeasible. When removal of a healthy tree is proposed, the completed evaluation would be made available during the public notification and protest process.
The City also received input from three advisory bodies, as summarized below.
Planning Board
The draft Plan was presented to the Planning Board on October 12, 2026, in recognition of the Tree Removal Policy's requirement for Planning Board and City Council review of capital projects involving removal of more than 5% of street trees on a block face. Although the Plan is not a capital project and does not authorize individual tree removals, staff sought the Board's review of the overall management framework before implementation begins. As discussed above, the Plan proposes a limited exception to this additional review requirement for future improvements undertaken in accordance with the adopted Plan.
Public comments emphasized the importance of preserving the mature Liquidambar canopy, further limiting tree removals, considering alternative infrastructure designs, and providing greater transparency and opportunities for community involvement. The Planning Board acknowledged the significant challenges associated with preserving the mature tree canopy while meeting ADA requirements and addressing deteriorating public infrastructure. Board members recognized staff's efforts to develop the Plan but thought the Plan needed additional detail, measurable criteria for evaluating tree-preservation approaches, and a more developed funding strategy. The Planning Board also thought more engagement through a neighborhood committee would be beneficial, and consideration should be given to establishing a special financing district. The Board did not raise specific concerns or recommend changes to the proposed replacement tree palette. The Board unanimously recommended that a revised draft Plan be brought back to the Planning Board for further consideration after revisions were made that address the comments raised by the Board and the public.
In response to the Planning Board's request for more detail on how the Plan will be implemented, staff developed a map showing the 42 locations where initial sidewalk and infrastructure improvements will be prioritized. The map provides a clearer understanding of where the City intends to focus its early efforts based on existing infrastructure conditions and accessibility needs. The Plan's location-by-location approach would be implemented through the City's existing Sidewalk Repair and Urban Forest Programs, which receive annual funding through the City Council's budget process. Specific repair methods and any potential tree removals would be determined through subsequent site-specific evaluations, allowing improvements to proceed incrementally as funding is available.
In response to concerns about the need for clearer and more consistent criteria for evaluating tree-preservation alternatives, staff developed the Tree Preservation Evaluation Form described earlier in this report. This additional documentation is intended to provide greater transparency and accountability in individual tree-removal decisions and would be made available to the public as part of the notification and protest process.
The Planning Board also suggested exploring the establishment of a special financing district to support improvements along Gibbons Drive. Special districts can provide a mechanism for property owners within a defined area to fund capital improvements or enhanced services beyond those ordinarily provided by the City. Depending on the intended purpose, a district could potentially fund a larger roadway reconstruction project or ongoing enhancements, such as larger replacement trees or additional tree maintenance. Formation of a district in an existing neighborhood would likely require property-owner support and funding for the City's administrative and consultant costs, typically through an upfront deposit covering district formation activities and required approval proceedings.
While a district could be explored in the future if there is sufficient neighborhood interest, staff is not recommending one at this time. The proposed Plan instead relies on the City's existing Sidewalk Repair and Urban Forest Programs, supported through the City Council's annual budget process, to implement improvements incrementally.
Commission on Persons with Disabilities
The Commission on Persons with Disabilities reviewed the draft Plan on October 14, 2026. Public comments echoed the themes presented to the Planning Board. Commissioners emphasized the importance of improving pedestrian accessibility, particularly for people who use wheelchairs, walkers, and other mobility devices. Their discussion highlighted the challenges presented by uneven and displaced sidewalks and the need to ensure that accessibility improvements are not unnecessarily delayed.
Commissioners also requested clarification regarding how individual locations would be evaluated, how alternative repair techniques would be considered, and how recommendations would be communicated to the public. Suggestions included prioritizing heavily used pedestrian routes and locations where accessibility barriers are particularly significant.
It was acknowledged that the existing tree canopy and accessible sidewalks are both important to the community, although prioritizing the Liquidambars over human accessibility needs raised concern. The Commission did not move to endorse the draft Plan and expressed its intention to call a special meeting to further discuss public comment and the Plan's revised elements.
Historical Advisory Board
During development of the Plan, the Liquidambar trees along Gibbons Drive were not designated as protected trees under the City's Protected Tree Ordinance, so review by the Historical Advisory Board (HAB) was not required. However, residents emphasized the trees' historical significance and their contribution to the neighborhood's character, with some requesting additional protection.
On October 20, 2026, City Council directed staff to prepare an ordinance designating the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as protected trees and present it as an alternative to the Plan. The HAB discussed the matter on November 5, 2026. Nine members of the public spoke, most of whom supported the designation. Public comments also raised questions about how the neighborhood's history of racially restrictive covenants should inform consideration of its historic significance.
Board members recognized the importance of the mature trees to Gibbons Drive's character and discussed several considerations regarding historic preservation, pedestrian accessibility, and the corridor's future. At the conclusion of the discussion, the following six points were summarized by Planning staff and acknowledged by the Board as reflecting its discussion:
• Equitable allocation of resources: Consider how City resources, including staff time and funding, are distributed equitably across neighborhoods and competing Citywide needs.
• Scope of historic protection: Consider whether historic significance should be associated with individual Liquidambar trees, the overall canopy and landscape, or the neighborhood's historic character.
• Tree preservation and accessibility: Consider tree removal as a last resort while recognizing the City's responsibility to provide safe and usable sidewalks.
• Protected-tree designation criteria: There is a need to better understand the basis for existing protected-tree designations under the Alameda Municipal Code. Without that information, it is difficult to establish why the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars should not receive similar protections. There is a similar need to address how protections are considered when a protected tree becomes less suitable due to age, climate change, or other factors.
• Decision-making process: Avoid creating an unnecessarily complex process for evaluating tree preservation and removal decisions.
• Community engagement: Ensure continued public participation and community engagement in decisions affecting the trees and corridor.
The draft ordinance prepared in response to the City Council's referral would designate the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as protected trees under the Alameda Municipal Code. The HAB discussion identified several considerations relevant to this proposal, including the scope of historic protection, the basis for existing protected-tree designations, and the process for evaluating future removal requests.
The draft Urban Forest Master Plan identifies an action for the Planning Department to update the City's Protected Tree Ordinance, providing an opportunity to consider designation criteria and review procedures more comprehensively. Staff believes it would be appropriate to address these broader questions through that process before pursuing designation of the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars. However, nothing precludes the City from considering designation now or at a later date. Staff's recommendation to adopt the Plan remains unchanged, as the Plan and the existing Tree Removal Policy already establish a preservation-first approach. If the trees are designated now or in the future, staff would comply with any additional applicable review and approval requirements.
Staff recommends that City Council adopt the resolution approving the Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan, including its location-by-location approach to infrastructure improvements and tree preservation, the 20% five-year removal cap, and the limited exception to the Tree Removal Policy's 5% block-face review requirement. Adoption would establish a framework for incremental improvements through the City's existing Sidewalk Repair and Urban Forest Programs, subject to annual funding through the City Council's budget process.
ALTERNATIVES
City Council may consider the following alternatives and others not listed here:
• Alternative 1: Take No Action. City Council could decline to adopt the Plan. Under this alternative, the City would address sidewalk hazards and accessibility deficiencies through existing programs and policies, without the benefit of a coordinated, corridor-wide framework to prioritize improvements, evaluate tree-preservation alternatives, manage the pace of tree removals, and guide replacement planting.
• Alternative 2: Adopt the Resolution after Directing Revisions to the Plan or Resolution. City Council could direct staff to make specific revisions to the Plan or proposed Resolution before adopting a revised Resolution.
Staff does not recommend this alternative unless there is very specific direction on the revisions. The Plan has been under development for approximately 18 months, and public comment has been underway for approximately one year. The City has a fiduciary responsibility to manage the public right-of-way, including compliance with ADA requirements and the management of street trees.
• Alternative 3: Adopt the Resolution and Direct Staff to Return for a First Reading of an Ordinance Designating the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as Protected Trees. At its October 20, 2026, meeting, City Council considered a referral to designate the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as protected trees under the Alameda Municipal Code. Following the discussion, City Council directed staff to prepare an ordinance for consideration as an alternative to the Plan when the Plan is presented to City Council. A draft ordinance, with proposed amendments to the Alameda Municipal Code shown in redline to add the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as protected trees, is included as Exhibit 3.
Staff does not recommend this alternative because the City's existing Tree Removal Policy, together with the proposed Plan, already establishes a preservation-first approach that requires evaluating alternatives before removing a healthy tree. Individual tree removals would also remain subject to the Tree Removal Policy's public notification and protest procedures, including a three-week period during which any member of the public may protest a proposed removal and the opportunity to appeal a removal decision to the City Council.
Designating the Liquidambars as protected trees would introduce an additional layer of review. In addition to the existing public protest process, staff would need to present the Tree Preservation Evaluation Form and supporting information to the HAB for consideration of a Certificate of Approval before proceeding with a proposed removal. This would place the HAB in the difficult position of weighing tree preservation against the City's legal obligations under the ADA, particularly when removal is determined to be necessary to provide an accessible pedestrian route. If the HAB denied a Certificate of Approval, staff would need to appeal that determination to the City Council for final policy direction on how to reconcile the competing considerations. Staff believes the existing Tree Removal Policy and proposed Plan provide a more appropriate framework for balancing tree preservation with the City's responsibility to maintain safe and accessible public infrastructure, while preserving opportunities for public input and City Council oversight.
• Alternative 4: Do not Adopt the Resolution and Direct Staff to Return for a First Reading of an Ordinance Designating the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as Protected Trees. Under this alternative, City Council would decline to adopt the Resolution and Plan and instead pursue the draft ordinance designating the Gibbons Drive Liquidambars as protected trees. The City would continue to address sidewalk hazards, accessibility deficiencies, and tree maintenance needs through existing programs and policies, subject to the additional requirements of the Protected Tree Ordinance.
Staff does not recommend this alternative because protected-tree designation alone would not establish a coordinated framework for prioritizing infrastructure improvements, evaluating preservation alternatives, managing the pace of canopy transition, or guiding replacement planting. In addition to the existing Tree Removal Policy's public notification, three-week protest period, and appeal procedures, proposed removals would require review by the HAB for a Certificate of Approval. This would place the HAB in the difficult position of weighing tree preservation against the City's legal obligations under the Americans with Disabilities Act, particularly where removal is determined necessary to address an accessibility barrier. If the HAB denied a Certificate of Approval, staff would need to appeal the determination to the City Council for final direction. Staff believes the recommended Plan provides a more comprehensive and effective approach to preserving the mature canopy while meeting the City's infrastructure and accessibility responsibilities.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Adoption of the Plan would not result in any immediate financial impact. Implementation would occur incrementally through the City's existing Sidewalk Repair and Urban Forest Programs, subject to funding appropriated by the City Council through the annual budget process.
Staff anticipates that the costs of implementing the Plan can generally be accommodated within existing program budgets. However, as specific improvements are identified and prioritized each year, staff may request additional appropriations to support implementation. Depending on the nature of the improvements, available funding, and competing transportation priorities, these requests could be supported by eligible transportation funding sources, such as Measure BB or Gas Tax revenues, or by the General Fund. Any additional funding requests would be brought to the City Council for consideration and approval.
MUNICIPAL CODE/POLICY DOCUMENT CROSS REFERENCE
City Strategic Plan, Project TIE19: Implement ADA plan for City programs, facilities, parks, streets, and sidewalk.
Master Street Tree Plan, 2010: recognized the value of Gibbons Drive’s mature Liquidambar canopy and the infrastructure conflicts with its extensive root systems. The plan recommended systematically replacing the Liquidambars over a 20-year period. The intent was to allow the canopy to transition incrementally over time and avoid the significant loss of canopy that could result from removing many trees at once.
Draft Urban Forest Master Plan, 2024: The publicly available draft of the Urban Forest Plan calls for a corridor-specific plan for Gibbons Drive. The draft plan emphasizes that available measures to mitigate tree-infrastructure conflicts should be considered before a tree is evaluated for removal.
Climate Action and Resiliency Plan, 2025: The Climate Action and Resiliency Plan (CARP) establishes a comprehensive framework to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and increase Alameda’s resilience to the effects of climate change. Urban greening is one of the Plan’s focus areas, with urban forestry identified as a strategy to increase carbon sequestration and provide additional environmental and community benefits. The CARP specifically calls for implementation of the City’s Urban Forest Plan to grow and maintain Alameda’s urban forest and increase tree canopy coverage.
Alameda Municipal Code, Article VII Section 13-21-Preservation of Historical and Cultural Resources Section 13-21 of the Alameda Municipal Code, Preservation of Historical and Cultural Resources, establishes regulations intended to preserve and protect resources that contribute to Alameda’s historical and cultural heritage. In addition to provisions addressing historic buildings, structures, sites, and districts, the ordinance provides specific protections for certain trees that meet the ordinance’s definition of a “protected tree.” Removal of a protected tree is subject to the review and approval procedures established by Section 13-21.
The Liquidambar trees along Gibbons Drive currently do not meet the definition of a protected tree under Section 13-21.
Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan, 2024: The ADA Plan identifies physical, programmatic, and policy barriers to accessibility and establishes a phased approach to remove them. The Gibbons Plan advances the goals of the ADA Transition Plan by establishing a framework to address sidewalk conditions that create accessibility barriers.
Active Transportation Plan, 2022. The Active Transportation Plan is intended to guide improvements that make walking, bicycling, and the use of mobility devices safer, more comfortable, and more accessible for people of all ages and abilities. The Plan recognizes sidewalks as an essential part of Alameda’s transportation network and emphasizes the importance of providing continuous and accessible pedestrian routes.
Alameda General Plan 2040, 2021: The Alameda General Plan 2040 establishes the City's overarching policy framework for land use, mobility, conservation, public infrastructure, and other matters affecting Alameda's physical environment. The General Plan is organized around four overarching themes: equity, environment, access, and preservation and enhancement of Alameda’s distinctive character and cultural diversity. It recognizes Alameda's extensive tree canopy, walkability, and livability as important characteristics of the community and calls for enhancing mobility and accessibility and improving safety on Alameda streets.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Adoption of the Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan is categorically exempt from environmental review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Sections 15301 (Existing Facilities) and 15308 (Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment).
Existing Facilities. CEQA Guidelines Section 15301 applies to the operation, repair, maintenance, and minor alteration of existing public facilities involving negligible or no expansion of existing or former use. The Plan provides a framework for targeted repair and maintenance of existing sidewalks, curbs, gutters, drainage facilities, and related infrastructure, as well as the management of existing street trees along Gibbons Drive. Implementation would occur on an as-needed, location-by-location basis and would not involve reconstruction of the entire corridor or expansion of the existing use. Section 15301 specifically identifies existing streets, sidewalks, gutters, pedestrian facilities, and street trees among the facilities and alterations that may qualify for the exemption.
Protection of the Environment. CEQA Guidelines Section 15308 applies to actions taken by regulatory agencies, as authorized by state or local ordinance, to assure the maintenance, restoration, enhancement, or protection of the environment where the regulatory process includes procedures for environmental protection. The City previously relied on this exemption when adopting the 2010 Master Street Tree Plan, which established policies for managing and protecting Alameda's urban forest. The Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan builds upon existing urban forest policies by establishing a location-specific decision-making framework that prioritizes the preservation of mature trees wherever feasible, requires consideration of feasible preservation measures before tree removal, limits the pace of tree removal, and requires replacement planting when removal is necessary.
CLIMATE IMPACT
The mature Liquidambar canopy provides important environmental benefits, including shade, urban cooling, carbon storage, and wildlife habitat. The Plan emphasizes preservation of mature trees wherever feasible and limits the pace of potential removals to reduce the likelihood of rapid canopy loss.
The Plan also includes a diverse palette of replacement trees intended to support a healthy and resilient urban forest over time. The City recognizes that newly planted trees will not immediately provide environmental benefits comparable to those of mature trees. However, as replacement trees grow and mature, they will increasingly contribute to shade, carbon storage, urban cooling, and habitat. By gradually transitioning to a canopy with greater species and age diversity, the City is planning for the long-term health and resilience of Gibbons Drive's urban forest while preserving the environmental benefits of the existing canopy for as long as feasible.
RECOMMENDATION
Adopt a resolution adopting the Gibbons Drive Sidewalks and Trees Plan, including a location-by-location approach to Infrastructure Improvements and Tree Preservation, a five-year tree removal cap, and an exception to the Tree Removal Policy's Five Percent Block-Face Review Requirement.
Respectfully submitted,
Erin Smith, Public Works Director
Financial Impact section reviewed,
John Stefanski, Interim Assistant City Manager/Acting Finance Director
Exhibits:
1. Gibbons Drive Sidewalk and Trees Plan
2. Gibbons Drive Sidewalk and Trees Plan Appendices
3. Draft Ordinance